Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
DEPARTMENT OF AVIATION
FINANCIAL OVERVIEW



 TRANSPORTATION AND ENVIRONMENT COMMITTEE
  •                                       January 9, 2006
2
Purpose of the Briefing
3
Financial Goals of the Department of Aviation
4

FY06 Adopted Operating Budget
5
Historical Operating Budget Expenses and Revenues Illustrates Surpluses and Shortfalls
6
CAFR Data FY00-FY04 (Revenues, Expenses, and Changes in Fund Equity (Net Assets)
7
Debt Background and Current Status
    • Favorable interest rates and desire to maintain strong cash position led to decision to issue bonds.  Strong cash position is desirable to:
      • Fund planned capital projects (see pages 38 & 39)
      • Retain financial flexibility
      • Prepare for emergencies
    • Debt assumed in 2001
    • Annual payments approximately $7.6 million
    • Debt obligation until 2011
    • $38.3M Outstanding as of September 30, 2005
    • Bonds have been downgraded to BBB/Baa2 with Stable Outlook by Moody’s and S&P
    • No further debt anticipated

8
DFW Debt Comparison
9
Finances
  • Aviation finances have been a concern
  • Fee and rate changes
    • Increased lease rates in 2001 and 2003
    • Increased parking rates in 2003
    • Increased fuel flow fees in 2003
    • In the spring of 2005, indicated to the major carrier that a landing fee increase would be required in the near future
10
  Rates And Charges
11
Leases
  • Rental payments received from tenants for leased property and improvements
    • Includes improved, unimproved ground rent and improvements
    • Major source of revenue given facilities that have been built over the years
  • Majority of leases contain escalation provisions
  • Rates are reviewed each year as part of budget
    • Adjustments recommended to cover operating costs or meet capital needs
  • Adjusting rates have mid (3-5 years)  and long term impact



12
Lease Philosophy
  • Generate revenue to cover operating costs and capital needs – now and in the future
    • Ensure airport maintains self-sufficiency pursuant to DOT/FAA grant assurances
  • Provide opportunity, through competitive rental rates, for private development and/or redevelopment of airport facilities
  • Create/Generate economic development opportunity
  • Create job opportunities
  • Broaden the City’s tax base


13
Lease Rate Comparison
14
Last Lease Rate Increase
  • Established New Prevailing Rate March 2003


    • Staff recommended establishing new prevailing ground annual rent rates at Dallas Love Field
      • Previous Current
    • Improved Ground (per sf) $ .26 $ .46
    • Unimproved Ground (per sf) $ .20 $ .32


    • New rate is at the mid-point of other comparable airports
    • Most leases adjusted to prevailing rental rates every three years not to exceed 12%

15
Parking
  • Parking revenue consists of fees collected for utilization of Love Field parking garages
  • Rates are established by ordinance
  • Dallas Love Field rates
    • $10.00 per day Garage A
    • $7.00 per day Garage B
  • Rates were last adjusted in April 2003 from $7 to $10 for Garage A, and from $5 to $7 for Garage B


16
Parking Rate Comparison
17
Concessions
  • Contracts obligating businesses to pay to operate a business on property including food and beverage services, retail stores, advertising, car rental agencies, etc.
  • Concession contracts awarded through competitive process
  • Pay either a percentage of their monthly gross revenues or a guaranteed minimum payment
  • Adjusting rates through new contracts has a 3-5 year impact


18
Concessions Comparison
19
Landing Fees
  • Fees paid by commercial aircraft owners to conduct operations at Dallas Love Field
  • Base rate is $.55 per 1,000 pounds.
  • Rates were amended in 1987 to encourage commercial airlines to use their quieter Stage III Aircraft at Love Field for $.35 per 1,000 pounds
    •  Current rate is $.35 per 1,000 pounds of landing
    •       weight for Stage III aircraft (now federally mandated)
    •  Adjusting rates would have immediate impact on
    •       revenues


20
Landing Fee Comparison
21
Fuel Flow Fees
  • Generated through General Aviation activity only
  • Fees collected from operators selling aircraft fuel at airports
  • $.07 cents per gallon, increased from $.04 in April 2003
  • Adjusting rates have immediate impact



22
Fuel Flow Fee Comparison
23
Revenues  (FY06 Budget)
24
FY06 Updated Revenues (Add 24 Flights)
25
Updated Revenues (Add 24 Flights)
26
 Landing Fees - Recommendation
  • Return To Single $.55 per 1,000 Pound Landing Fee
    • $.35 Stage III incentive no longer applicable
    • Allows for a slightly better than "break even" annual financial projection
27
FY06 Updated Revenues (24 Flights + $.55 Landing Fee)
28
Updated Revenues (24 Flights + $.55 Landing Fee)
29
Next Steps

  • Brief Council on Wright Amendment January 18, 2006 (background and history)
  • Council Action on Landing Fees February 22, 2006 (to be Effective April 1, 2006)
  • Review Rates and Charges to consider additional changes to be recommended with the FY2007 Budget
30
Appendix
  • Aviation Department Cash Balances (p. 30)
  • City Auditor’s Report on Lease Practices (p. 31)
  • Report of Real Estate Task Force (p. 33)
  • City Auditor’s Report on 9-1-1 Emergency Service Fee (p. 34)
  • Funding Options For Improved Transit (p. 35)
  • Capital Improvement Plan (p. 38)
  • Enplanements (p. 40)



31
Aviation Cash Balances
32
City Auditor’s Report on Lease Practices
  • City Audit on “Aviation Lease and Rental Agreements” released January 14, 2005
  • Overall Conclusion:
    • “… staff adequately ensured that lease/rental payments were in accordance with contract provisions, that rental payments were paid on a  timely basis, and that the rental revenues are properly accounted for and recorded”
33
City Auditor’s Report on Lease Practices
  • Opportunities for Improvements
    • Length of month-to-month leases
      • Council review of month to month leases
        • Council committee briefed March 7, 2005
      • Standardize lease form
        • Developed and being used
    • Accounting of all leasehold improvements
      • Staff agreed
    • Rental rates should be set to sustain airport
      • Staff sets rates to sustain the airport
      • Agreed to annual review of rates and charges



34
Real Estate Task Force Report
  • Task Force reviewed leasing procedures of the department
    • Council briefing included as an attachment
    • Council briefed on March 2, 2005
  • General findings
    • “The committee was generally impressed with the polices and procedures related to the Aviation Department”
    • A high quality standard lease form is currently being used
    • “… it seems that the existing airports are in a good consolidated economic position”
  • Recommendations
    • Recommended several technical changes to standard lease form
    • Established material lease provisions
    • Annual review of month-to-month leases
    • Annual review of rental rates
35
City Auditor’s Report on 9-1-1 Emergency Service Fee
  • City Audit on released May 13, 2005
    • Review covered sources, uses and restriction of fees in the administration of 9-1-1 services.
  • Recent media report highlighted loan of $2.3 from Aviation Construction Fund
    • Did not adhere to policy related to transfer of funds
  • Staff Response:
    • Met the requirement of AD 4-5
    • Loan was not an expenditure of funds
    • Loan was fully documented between departments
    • Loan was recommended to the City Council in a briefing prior to it execution
    • Payment identified in FY 2004-05 Budget document
    • Funds are being repaid with interest
    • Staff agrees to bring to Council
36
Funding Options for Improved 
Transit
37
Funding Transit Access
  • Issues regarding transit access to Love Field
    • Mode and Alignment
    • Cost Benefit
    • Cost sharing
    • Ease of Access



38
Funding Transit Access
  • Funding options
    • “Pay As You go” Approach
    • Bond Financing
    • Passenger Facility Charge
      • Construct Station
      • Pledge for financing
  • Present funding plan once mode of transit and alignment is determined


39
Aviation Capital Improvement Plan
40
Aviation Capital Improvement Plan Continued -
41
Enplanements: FY 1998 – FY 2005